Blogs I read

NYT Bits
Broadband Reports
The Bauminator
Blog Maverick
Multichannel News
MCN Bit Rate
NewTeeVee
CableFAX
CableTechTalk
BC Beat
Engadget HD
Sherman on Security
The 'Ville Voice
Louisville Mojo - Rick Redding

My pages

Visit my Facebook profile
Visit my YouTube channel

Why I'm doing this

It's conventional wisdom. When it comes to communicating with the public, most companies take the safest path. They usually play their cards pretty close to their chest. I'm joining the blogsosphere to challenge that "wisdom."

Read more

Comments policy

Comments are posted immediately. I review the comments and will remove those that are not germane to the topics being discussed on the blog. Individual customer issues will be removed if posted. If you have a specific issue with your Insight service that you have been unable to resolve, feel free to contact me at michaelwillner@insightbb.com.

« Site allows P2Pers to reimburse content creators | Main | New mobile television standard announced »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e5520719b088340120a63f0d93970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Following up on this week's annoucements:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

JDF

I hate it when people put me in the position to defend Insight but... I'm reading some complaints about the picture quality on some of the HD channels and, other than the fact that Insight went to the trouble of adding the channels at all, it is not Insight's fault. You say some HD channel programs look like upscaled SD? Well, surprise! That's exactly what they are, because that is what the channel is broadcasting. Many HD channels have very, very little true HD programming, so you end up with upscaled, sometimes even stretched, SD programming that looks like crap. Those that don't upscale and/or strech may even simply zoom (hello PBS and History Channel). Again, though, not Insight's fault. Maybe the channels aren't really worth of being watched, but Insight likely got a very good deal on the channels for exactly that reason and you can't blame them for adding new HD channels regardless of how much true HD programming is presented on them...

DM

JDF,

I don’t think that people are complaining about the lack of HD content or stretching on “HD” channels, rather people are complaining because Insight degrades the quality of actual HD channels by decreasing the bit rate of the MPEG-2 video stream. For example, when I had Insight for TV I saw a lot of pixilation and macro blocking on ESPN and ESPN2. I also saw this during Fox Sports events shown on the “Special Events” channel.

I now have MPEG-4 video streams with Dish Network and do not experience the pixilation or macro blocking. Since the MPEG-4 stream uses less bandwidth, Dish doesn’t have to compress the video stream as much. This is true of other providers that utilize MPEG-4 (non-cable) rather than MPEG-2 (cable).

I guess it may be hard to understand, but if you have never compared the cable HD signal with another provider, you probably wouldn’t think there is a major difference between the two. However, once you do experience the increased quality that an MPEG-4 stream can provide, then it is hard to accept anything less.

JDF

DM,

Maybe not everyone was, but that's exactly what it appeared that some were complaining about. Especially when comparing certain channels to others. Not everyone realizes that just because a channel is labeled HD, it doesn't mean that they actually broadcasting all HD programming.

Ghpr57

In all fairness I felt I should let everyone here know that yesterday, the 19th, Insight left a message on my voice mail.(It seems that someone from Insight does read these comments). Insight would like to talk to me about the problems I'm having with my service(I guess the slowdown on my broadband). I haven't had a chance yet to return the call. When I do I'll post back here with info on what happened.
BTW: I'm wondering a bit on how they were able to put my comments together with whom I am??? I used a "spam" e-mail address, not my personal e-mail address.

DM

JDF,

I get what you are saying. I have a keen eye for such things and can easily spot when content is 4:3 SD and being stretched and upconverted. I will admit that some people can't recognize this as well as others. I don't think it helps that the default DVR box settings stretch and upconvert SD signals either.

Ghpr57,

Perhaps there was information collected at another web site or forum. Also, your IP address may have been logged on this site, as stated in the "Privacy Policy".

Annoyed

Anonymous,

I know all about 16x9 aspect ratio and it has nothing to do with the problems we have with Insight's HD. (read: I'm not watching HD in the wrong aspect ratio) If you work for Insight, that shows how much Insight employees know about HD.

It is a bandwidth and compression issue. Period.

Greg

I hate when I make a comment about the problems I have with Insight's HD, people assume I'm ignorant and don't know about aspect ratio and SD upconversion.

Let me state this again....

My HD channels through Insight are hit or miss. Some channels look pretty good. Others look pretty bad at times (too much compression). Some of us get a lot of pixelation and macroblocking on our HD channels. Also there are times when my HD channels freeze completely or go black.

My friend has DirecTV HD channels and the picture quality blows Insight away.

Ghpr57

DM,
Thanks for that reply. I wasn't thinking about my IP address, Duh! You are probably correct on that. Thanks again!

ARGO

I hate to say it but this over-compression issue will probably be around for ten years or until some major software and hardware changes are made.

Welcome to the digital age.

JDF

Curious how after being brought up here, MLB just sent out an email this afternoon to people on its mailing list that it identified as Insight customer asking them to call Insight to request MLB Network be added to the Insight channel lineup...

Ghpr57

Well I talked to a rep at Insight today. She wanted to know if she could help me with the problems I posted about on here. I explained that I appreciate her contacting me, but it's a day late & a dollar short. When I had Insight's cable service and complained about their Motorola DVR and the remote, I was told "that's just how it is." (Once I was even told "I should turn the DVR off each night & turn it back on in the morning, because it's like a computer and shouldn't be left on all the time.") She apologized for what happened in the past and she said they went ahead and did a check on my broadband and everything checked out fine. She advised me that the next time I experience a slow down, to call Insight right then so they can check it out. I thanked her for her time.

Rob Jones

Do to the fact that I am an effective user of the internet for things like, movies, tv, games and demos, software, music, etc. I upgraded to 20.0 to get the extra speed. I was a 20.0 user for about a year. After the economy tanked I recently made budget cuts like canceling cable television and went back down to 10.0.

I wasn't looking forward to the slower speed. After a month on 10.0 I can honestly say that I haven't noticed the difference between it and 20.0. And my use of the internet has slightly increased.

In Hong Kong you can get 100Mbps for $30 per month. The U.S. is so far behind when it comes to internet speeds.

I don't think people download more just because they have a faster speed, they just spend less time waiting for it. Everyones internet use will increase exponentially on a regular basis and ISPs aren't ready for it because their executives need to be super rich and are out of touch with real people.

ISPs should be concerned when John McCain (who doesn't own a computer or know how to use the internet) is trying to help make sure the free internet remains free.

Michael, seeing that you don't even live in an Insight covered area are you qualified to know how good the service is? I know I am, I've been using it since it was @Home. Your new 30.0 is not worth what you be charging for it, I don't care what Time Warner tells you.

ARGO

"The new Broadband 30.0 service will be priced at a $15 monthly premium over the cost of our 20.0 service."

Think about this... $15 + two yearly 'across the board' rate increases for just a 1.5meg upload increase.

Ryan

So when is 30.0 coming out? So much hype and stating December release. Nothing besides "coming soon"? We are entitled to an update do you think?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

 Subscribe | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2008-2011 Michael Willner. All Rights Reserved.